1-04-2004 ICRC visits to people deprived of their freedom Categories of prisoners visited by the ICRC
As regards internal disturbances and any other situation that calls for action on the part of a specifically neutral and independent organization, there is no single feature common to all detainees entitled to ICRC protection. The ICRC is concerned with persons arrested on account of a situation of internal strife - whatever the government may call them or the legislation used to deprive them of their freedom. It is clearly not enough to think in terms of a detainee's political motives. For example, many people needing ICRC protection may , have been arrested solely on account of their ethnic or other origin, without having ever been politically committed in any way. Nor can the ICRC just consider the offence ascribed to the detainees. Political opponents are sometimes imprisoned for criminal offences, such as disruption of public order, vagrancy or illegal possession of firearms. The penal code in many States qualifies as criminal offences activities which may in fact be of a political nature. In addition, the decision to charge a detainee under a particular law may be founded on purely arbitrary considerations. Each of the above criteria may be useful, but none is sufficient in itself. The ICRC may request access to detainees as different as a captured guerrilla, a peasant accused of collaboration with the armed opposition, a student who has demonstrated against those in power or a member of an ethnic group held in connection with events that have prompted the ICRC to offer its services. All these detainees have in common the fact that, rightly or wrongly, they are considered by the detaining authority as real or potential opponents. Here it should be pointed out that the type of offence of which a detainee is accused, whether sabotage, acts of terrorism, subversion or dissidence, is of no importance to the ICRC. The ICRC never questions the reason for a person's arrest. |