In today's armed conflicts, civilians continue to bear the brunt of violence: cities reduced to rubble, hospitals destroyed, patients killed, and humanitarian and medical personnel targeted. We face both a crisis of compliance with the rules of war and a crisis of collective conscience. The precedents set today will haunt us for years.
International humanitarian law (IHL) makes clear that the choice of means and methods of warfare is not unlimited. The CCW was established to limit the devastation of war through specific prohibitions and restrictions on the most unacceptable conventional weapons.
The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) has submitted a working paper to this Review Conference, setting out its views and recommendations to support High Contracting Parties' deliberations.
Let us take a step back and reflect on the Convention's achievements, its shortcomings and the lessons these offer for the future.
Together with its five Protocols, the CCW is a major pillar of IHL. Its greatest achievements are arguably Protocols I and IV. They protected combatants and civilians against, respectively, weapons causing injury through fragments undetectable by X-rays and blinding laser weapons, before these weapons entered military arsenals. This is humanitarian disarmament at its best.
Restrictions on incendiary weapons, mines and booby-traps; the regulation of explosive remnants of war; and the extension of the scope of the Convention to apply to non-international armed conflicts are further important achievements.
But these successes must not obscure the challenges.
Universalization has slowed considerably. We must reverse this trend through tailored engagement with states not party to the Convention and greater synergies with other humanitarian disarmament treaties. In addition, membership must translate into effective national implementation, including through greater use of the Implementation Support Unit’s Implementation Guide.
Above all, states must demonstrate that the Convention remains relevant and capable of addressing the humanitarian challenges posed by conventional weapons, both old and new.
What lessons from the past should guide this Review Conference?
Forty-six years after the adoption of Protocol III, serious concerns persist over the human cost of incendiary weapons and white phosphorus. Concerns also persist over anti-vehicle mines, despite Amended Protocol II. The last CCW prohibitions or restrictions on specific weapons date back 30 years, and the latest Protocol was adopted more than 20 years ago. Meanwhile, experience with anti-personnel mines, cluster munitions and explosive weapons in populated areas shows that states may seek solutions outside the CCW when humanitarian concerns remain unaddressed.
The Review Conference should therefore ensure that these outstanding issues – particularly the human cost of weapons with incendiary effects and mines other than anti-personnel mines (MOTAPM) – are addressed without further delay.
Let us turn now to autonomous weapons, where the need for action is urgent.
Research and development in the field of autonomous weapons is advancing rapidly, and the military use of such weapons is expanding.
The development and use of autonomous weapons are already governed by IHL. But these weapons also raise specific humanitarian, ethical, legal, proliferation, and peace and security concerns. For nearly 13 years, states have examined these issues in the CCW with military, technical, legal and humanitarian experts to understand the risks and identify the necessary limits.
The progress made by the Group of Government Experts on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems during the last review cycle provides a strong and sufficient basis for launching negotiations on a new CCW protocol, notwithstanding the ICRC's reservations about certain omissions in the Group’s report. Moreover, on 29 October, 163 states, including more than 100 CCW High Contracting Parties, voted in favour of a UN General Assembly First Committee resolution calling for negotiations on an international instrument.
The foundations have been laid. The need is urgent.
In August, the ICRC president and the UN secretary-general reiterated their joint call for the urgent adoption of clear prohibitions and restrictions on autonomous weapons. They warned that autonomous targeting of human beings by machines is a moral red line that must not be crossed.
It is not for the developers of military technologies alone to determine what is acceptable. States must set the necessary boundaries now. They must preserve meaningful human control over the use of force. Once unacceptable systems are widely deployed, the risks to civilians and international security will be far harder to contain.
Codifying and progressively developing IHL to address the specific challenges posed by autonomous weapons fall squarely within the CCW's remit. A new protocol is urgently needed, expressly prohibiting unpredictable autonomous weapons and those designed or used to target human beings directly, and establishing clear restrictions on all others.
As the ICRC president stated on 13 November:
“States have the crucial responsibility to ensure that the future of warfare is not handed over to machines. … The risks are too great. After years of discussion, the time for action is now. States must launch negotiations on a new protocol before it is too late.”
A one-year negotiating mandate for a new protocol on autonomous weapons would be the most significant outcome of this Review Conference. It would demonstrate that the Convention remains credible and capable of addressing contemporary challenges, while delivering on its fundamental promise: to alleviate human suffering in war.