Promoters of AI-based systems have claimed that they can enhance compliance with IHL and minimize risks for civilians.
In certain circumstances, the careful and responsible use of AI DSS may facilitate quicker and more comprehensive information analysis, which can support decisions in a way that enhances IHL compliance and minimizes risks for civilians.
For instance, the use of AI DSS can assist in collecting and synthesizing information from open-source repositories online about the presence of civilians and civilian objects or support weaponeering by recommending means and methods of attack that can best avoid, or at least minimize, incidental civilian harm. The effectiveness of any such tool will still be subject to inherent limitations of the technology and will depend upon access to good quality data.
Unfortunately, many of the conflicts today in which the most technologically sophisticated weapons and systems are employed, we have not seen better outcomes for civilians but rather the most widespread and indiscriminate devastation. The qualities advertised in new technologies have led not to precision, distinction and precaution, but to acceleration, amplification and escalation of destruction, with appalling results for civilians.
Ultimately, the impact on civilians of AI DSS will depend on the way they are designed and used.
Importantly, the use of AI-decision-support systems can never ameliorate targeting methodologies and other policies that do not otherwise comply with IHL; applying AI-decision-support systems within such frameworks will serve only to replicate and likely exacerbate unlawful or otherwise harmful effects faster and on a larger scale.